Key Takeaways

  • Other Mommy debuted at No. 1 with a $27.8 million opening weekend, the biggest new release of the month so far.
  • Critics are a lot colder on it than audiences showing up, with reviews calling it generic and over reliant on jump scares.
  • I think a genuinely great premise got buried under studio horror formula, and that’s the most 2026 horror story there is.

Jump to:

Horror had a big weekend. Other Mommy, the new movie from director Rob Savage, pulled in $27.8 million and took the top spot at the box office, easily beating out Verity and the horror crowd still sticking around theaters. I love when horror wins a weekend. I don’t love that the reviews are telling a very different story than the box office chart.

What Other Mommy Is Actually About

Other Mommy is based on Josh Malerman’s 2024 novel Incidents Around the House. If that name sounds familiar, Malerman also wrote Bird Box, so he’s got a track record of turning one simple, scary idea into something people can’t stop talking about.

The movie follows Bela, an eight year old girl played by newcomer Arabella Olivia Clark, who starts noticing something strange coming out of her bedroom closet while her parents’ marriage falls apart around her. The presence starts whispering to her and eventually takes the form of a figure she calls Other Mommy. Jessica Chastain and Jay Duplass play her actual parents, with Dichen Lachman and the legendary Karen Allen rounding out the cast.

Rob Savage directed this one, and that matters to me. His found footage movie Host is one of the smartest horror films of the last few years, made for basically nothing and genuinely unsettling start to finish. James Wan’s Atomic Monster produced this alongside Blumhouse, which tells you exactly what kind of machine built this movie.

The Box Office Numbers Don’t Lie, But They Don’t Tell You Much Either

A $27.8 million opening weekend is a real number. It’s more than double what the next closest movie made, and Universal reportedly moved this thing from a spring 2026 slot to October specifically to cash in on the Halloween crowd. That decision paid off.

But box office success and quality have had almost nothing to do with each other for years now, especially in horror. I made basically this same point a few weeks back when Black Phone 2 buried Tron: Ares at the box office. Horror is cheap to make, the built in audience shows up opening weekend no matter what, and word of mouth only starts mattering for the back half of the run. Other Mommy is a textbook case of a studio nailing the release date and marketing, independent of whether the movie itself is actually good.

What the Reviews Are Actually Saying

Here’s where it gets rough. Dread Central gave it a 2 out of 5 and called it “a generic funhouse of horror that’s seldom scary.” That’s a brutal pull quote, and from what I’m reading elsewhere, it’s not an outlier opinion.

The praise that is out there is specific and consistent. Arabella Olivia Clark is reportedly the best part of the movie, giving a performance that’s genuinely heartbreaking for an eight year old lead. Chastain is effective as the menacing mother figure, which is a strange sentence to type about someone with an Oscar, but horror has always been generous to actors willing to go somewhere dark. The shapeshifting creature design apparently has a few fun moments too.

The criticism is where the pattern shows up. The story reportedly falls apart once the family actually learns what they’re dealing with, the scares turn repetitive and noisy instead of building dread, and there’s a late twist that undercuts the movie’s whole point about divorce and a kid’s fear of her family falling apart. That part stings the most if it’s true, because that premise is genuinely great. A kid processing her parents splitting up by watching a monster literally replace her mom is a better horror metaphor than ninety percent of what gets greenlit these days.

My Take: A Great Premise That Got Chickened Out Of

I haven’t seen it yet, so take this as a prediction more than a verdict. But I’ve watched this exact pattern play out enough times to call it. Studio horror keeps finding genuinely great emotional hooks, divorce, grief, whatever it is, and then smothering them in jump scares and CG because test audiences apparently want to be startled every six minutes instead of unsettled for two hours.

Rob Savage knows how to be unsettling. Host proved that. If the reports are accurate and this one leans on noise and CG instead of the dread he’s clearly capable of building, that’s a real shame, not a surprise.

Here’s my actual recommendation. Read Malerman’s book first if divorce horror as a concept interests you at all, since novels don’t have a marketing team telling them to add three more jump scares in the third act. Then go see the movie for Chastain and the kid’s performance, and go in expecting a fun Friday night horror movie instead of the generational family horror story the premise promises. Lower the bar a little and you’ll probably have a good time. Just don’t expect Host.

The official trailer for Other Mommy.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Other Mommy about?

Other Mommy follows an eight year old girl named Bela whose parents’ marriage is falling apart while a supernatural presence emerges from her bedroom closet and takes the form of a figure she calls Other Mommy.

Who stars in Other Mommy?

Jessica Chastain and Jay Duplass play Bela’s parents, with newcomer Arabella Olivia Clark as Bela, alongside Dichen Lachman and Karen Allen. Rob Savage directed from a screenplay by Nathan Elston.

Is Other Mommy based on a book?

Yes. It’s adapted from Josh Malerman’s 2024 novel Incidents Around the House. Malerman also wrote Bird Box.

How much did Other Mommy make at the box office?

Other Mommy opened at No. 1 with a $27.8 million domestic weekend, more than double what the next closest movie earned.

Is Other Mommy worth watching?

Reviews are mixed. Critics have praised the lead performances but called the back half of the movie formulaic and overly reliant on jump scares. It’s worth seeing for the cast, but go in with tempered expectations.